Noob Report 2: How it's going, 10 months later

General
1

Summary

I started with Logseq in September 2024. I posted my early impressions here. Since then, I’ve been using LS nearly every workday. This is an update of my experience, perhaps of some value to others who are considering a move to Logseq.

Priors

  • Windows 11

  • I’m a happy v0.10 camper. I’m not paying much attention to what’s happening with the db version. My expectation is that it will be fine and I won’t notice much difference if/when the day comes that I must make the switch. I notice a lot of agita about the state of Logseq development and comparisons to other platforms, and honestly, it just doesn’t concern me . Logseq already has significantly advanced my knowledge capture and workflow management. If the devs call it quits tomorrow and never write another line of code, I’ll be indefinitely happy with the way Logseq works today.

  • Strictly desktop. I don’t use, or want, access to Logseq by mobile device. I am a mobile minimalist anyway: no work-related apps or content. It can wait.

  • For this reason, I don’t worry about sync issues. The \assets, \journals, \logseq and \pages directories are stored in my Windows Documents directory, which is automatically backed up to OneDrive by virtue of my Win11 settings. It’s not sync, it’s backup, which is all I really need.

  • I spent most of this time in the original theme. More recently I’ve adopted the Bonofix theme, which I like very much.

What problem was I trying to solve?

I was coming from many years of using OneNote to manage a GTD-esque workflow.

OneNote is a natural GTD platform. You can quickly set up lists for next actions, waiting, etc. You can build a warehouse for reference material. It integrates tightly with Outlook and other Office tools. OneNote is a near-perfect digital version of the analog office with inboxes, to-do-baskets and file cabinets full of paper.

And that also is OneNote’s chief drawback. It may be a digital platform, but like the paper-shuffling office, it is a manual environment, for the most part. Managing GTD in OneNote required lots of clerical touch points: changing the status of tasks, for example. It was cumbersome to create and maintain associations among scattered bits of information — stuff that had more than one relationship. Above all, there was the friction of where — i.e., determining the proper location for each new input or status change. Do the meeting notes go in “meetings”? Or do they go with the project? Both? What if my meeting notes deal with multiple projects? What if a new input is not related to a project and is just a good idea I need to follow up with someone? Where does that go? Etc. I found myself nodding along to @alanyoung as he described this fundamental flaw with a file-and-folder system.

Logseq’s essential insight — blocks and backlinks — seemed to solve the where issue right out of the box.

Still, my chief anxiety at the start was finding stuff. In OneNote, when the question was “where is it?” I had to know the answer. In Logseq I have to know how to ask the question. There’s a difference, and at first, it was a bit of a leap into the unknown.

Learning how to ask LogSeq the right question is a bit of a skill, and it took some practice. I built some tools, methods and documentation that help. Over time, my where anxiety abated. These days I dump new info into my journal with no worry I’ll be able to retrieve it when the need arises.

Biggest wins so far

Templates

I’ve built a template for the daily journal. It’s wired into logseq/config.edn so that the template is inserted into each new day’s journal. The template is built mostly along GTD lines: Inbox, do, delegate, defer; plus a section for meetings. I also have a template for meetings and for project dashboards.

Agendas

The #agenda tag and query are at the top of the list of benefits of how I’ve been using LS so far.

I have lots of meetings. I need to feel confident that when it’s meeting time, I’ve got a current, complete list of topics we need to discuss.

Whenever a topic, fact, question, etc. comes up during note-taking, or just pops into my head and I jot it into the journal, the block is tagged with the person’s [[Name]] and with the #agenda hashtag. This is real easy for capturing I need to talk to [[Name]] about this

Then I created a separate Agenda page. It has a list of blocks. Each block is a different person, or team, with whom/which I have meetings, either regularly scheduled or as-needed. Each one of those persons or teams is their own [[Page]]

Each of those blocks contains a query that returns the person/group’s [[Name]] page and the #agenda hashtag.

Before the meeting

  • I go to the Agenda page, and open the block corresponding to the person or group with whom I am meeting
  • Copy the block embed of the query. That’s important: it’s the block embed of the query, not of the blocks returned by the query
  • Back on the Journal page, I paste the query block embed into the agenda section of the meeting template. This displays all the topics I need to discuss with the person or team.

After the meeting

  • I delete the #agenda hashtag from each block in the query block embed that is pasted in the Agenda section of the meeting.
  • This removes the item from the query and thus also the meeting template – not a loss because my discussion notes are already entered in the meeting template. It also moves the block outside the scope of the query running on the Agenda page in the block associated with that person or group’s name. It cleans up both places at once.
  • This routine, by itself, has made the investment in learning LogSeq worth it. It has been, so far, the most concrete manifestation of the “second brain” attribute of a PKMS. And the most direct realization of frictionless entry/complete recall.

Project dashboards

An essential element of GTD is managing multi-step projects. Because projects tend to span significant stretches of time, inputs tend to trickle in: an email today, a report next week, a meeting on Friday, etc. It’s easy to dump these inputs into Logseq via the journal. The critical issue is keeping these bits connected to the project, and being able to recall them.

In my system, each project gets a [[project name]]. Each parent block related to the project – notes of meeting, etc. – includes the [[project name]]

For each project I also build a dashboard. The dashboard is a Logseq template that I built, and it contains basic project info: name, purpose, principals, a section for links to resource materials, and a task list, which is continually updated. I explained how the task list works here.

I keep a page that is nothing but a query that displays a list of all projects, with links to their dashboards. This gives me a one-stop place to find all projects and quickly click in to their dashboards.

Biggest challenges so far

Email

Managing email is essential to any workflow. Email contains inputs that need to be dumped into the GTD inbox, assessed, and tracked. Because my GTD Inbox is in my Logseq daily journal, I need a way to make new emails visible there. But I also do not want to allow hundreds, and eventually thousands, of emails to pile up indefinitely in the assets folder. I need a way to move email into Logseq, and also a method to remove email from \assets when it’s no longer needed. (See Bloat, below).

Microsoft Exchange (Outlook) does not integrate with Logseq, so managing email is a manual, somewhat clunky, process. This is Logseq’s weakest link. Here’s the method I’ve devised:

Email for projects

Whenever I create a new project, I anticipate I will be receiving regular email about that project. Accordingly, in Outlook I create a new folder and give it the same name as [[Project Name]] in Logseq. I keep all of it there. Over in Logseq, in the project dashboard, I enter a block that reminds me that all email related to the project is stored in that Outlook folder.

As email arrives in Outlook, I determine if the email is related to a project I am managing. If yes, then:

  • I move the email into the Outlook folder created for the project
  • Over in Logseq, I create a new block in the GTD inbox with a quick Email: [[Project name]] note that alerts me to the new email. Later, as I work through the GTD inbox, the note will prompt me to review the email.
  • After I review the email, I will update the Logseq block with appropriate GTD instruction (and move it to the proper GTD category.

Standalone email (not related to a project)

  • I save the email to my local \attachments directory as a .msg file, then in Logseq I /upload the .msg file to the daily journal GTD inbox. After I’ve cleared the Outlook inbox, I’ll jump over to Logseg and work through the GTD Inbox, opening the .msg files as I come to them. I will assess the emails under the GTD method, and either deal with the email immediately or move it into the Next Actions list per the GTD method.

  • When emails are no longer needed, I search/delete the .msg file from \assets and delete the block from Logseq.

All of this is less than elegant and, so far, has proven to be Logseq’s No. 1 weakness in my use case. But with time this workaround has become more committed to muscle memory and is only a minor inefficiency.

Everyday stuff I use

  • Logseq Mastery course, by Dario da Sylva. I’m not even halfway through the course. I go through a new chunk every now and then. It’s been a worthwhile investment of money and time. I find comfort in having it at handy as a reference. If you don’t want to spend the money, Dario has made a slice of his course available for free on YouTube , and it will get you a good way up the learning curve all by itself.

  • aText text expander. This is a suggestion I picked up from Dario, and I’m glad I did. I use aText to:

    • Apply markdown in Logseq, especially for headings. Typing #3 applies the ### Markdown code to the block, for example
    • Assign properties to blocks
    • Type query strings, e.g. there’s an aText command that will type out the and query syntax. I just fill in the search values.
    • Fill out my keyboard shorthand, e.g. aText will turn cd into could.

  • Self-edited help page. As I discover new things about Logseq that I want to remember, I keep notes about them in a help page of my own making.

  • Queries library. Similarly, as I devise new queries that I know I want to use again, I keep a page dedicated to them, explaining their purpose and spelling out the query string syntax. Then I build aText shortcuts that will invoke the query.

  • Reference material. Long-term storage of reference material is kept in One Note, not Logseq. Links to the OneNote sections/pages are placed in Logseq blocks as necessary. Those blocks are given a gtd property value of reference. That way, an and query can call up links to reference material associated with a given search term or page or project.

Stuff I still haven’t figured out

The Deadline and Scheduled functions

How do these relate to the daily journal? It remains a mystery to me. In particular, I have not yet figured out how to have the journal display only those dated items that are due, or scheduled, for the current day. It’s just the same dated items in a list, every day.

Stuff I worry about

Bloat

Saving email messages seems wasteful. The message (A) already is stored in Outlook local directory. Then a copy (B) must be saved to another location. That copy is then uploaded (C) to Logseq and stored in the assets folder. That’s 3x the storage for the same email. To prevent bloat, I have to delete B and C when the email is no longer needed.

Similarly, I am careful about uploading documents to Logseq. Once there is no longer a need to keep a document close at hand, I will move it from assets to long-term storage in OneNote.

When TODO items are complete, I tend to delete the block, not merely mark the item as done — unless the task is part of a project task list. I will delete the entire list when the project is done.

I don’t know whether bloat is a justified worry. If not, I am trying to regularly prune the ever-accumulating blocks in the graph, in the name of good PKM platform hygiene.

5 Likes